G&P vs. ICS vs. KWA M4/M16

[phucheneh]

frankly i don't see why anyone would feel the need for anything higher than the ROF on a kwa with a 9.6. and the gun has EXCELLENT durability with that fairly high ROF and 400fps+ capability. all the gun needs is an inner barrel. only compatibility issue is the hopup, and you don't want to replace that. at worst the lower hopup cracks or something and you have to buy the part from kwa for a reasonable price.

no experience with the others, though there are things i like about both. would like to try the 2 piece ICS gearbox at some point, but for a solid field gun out of the box i'd say kwa. G&P, G&G, and other taiwanese manufacturers have decent guns but they clock a decent bit lower on the chrono out of the box. VFC's are more up in KWA territory, and they're some solid guns. gearbox doesn't seem quite as advanced as the KWA, though.

[shadow99117]

Well, Iv been looking some more, and heres what iv come up with
KWA SR12: http://www.airsoftpost.com/product_info ... s_id=31647
VFC 416: http://www.airsoftpost.com/product_info ... s_id=33414
G&P M4 Defender: http://www.airsoftpost.com/product_info ... s_id=30096

They All have good arguments, the fact that the G&P includes a red dot, foregrip, and rail covers is cool. I LOVE the look of the 416 though. And then theres the absolute reliability of the KWA, and it would be nice to know that the gun, unless your unluck/abusive/etc. will never break. How is VFC internally? Iv never heard much about there internals, but only that there externals are almost equal to G&P.

[21cubs]

SR12 All the way. Then just deck out the externals from there and you have a perfect gun.

[The Specialist]

G&P. Period.

[chrisdetrin]

KWA SR-12 hands down.

[trevorst]

[chrisdetrin]

kwa + marui bucking and promy barrel = god gun.

[trevorst]

[shadow99117]

Well, any gun will need upgrading eventually, but the KWA would be better out of the box than the G&P.... But, if I get the G&P, Il put in a new gear set and piston right off the bat.